Thursday, September 1, 2011

Follow My Book Blog Friday Hop #8

Happy Follow Friday!!


Happy Labor Day Weekend!!!!

This weekly feature is hosted by
Rachel at Parajunkee's View 
Alison at Alison Can Read,
 which you really must go and check out!!

Rachel not only has fabulous features,
but is a web designer
'par excellence'!!
Alison has a beautiful and very
interesting blog!

You can find the rules at the links above.
Join in the fun and make new blogging friends!!

This week's featured blogs are:


Here's this week's question:

If you could change the ending
of any book (or series),
which book would you choose?
Why and to what?

I love this question!  For me, there's absolutely no doubt as to which book I would choose: Gaston Leroux's The Phantom of the Opera.



For a long time, I actually avoided reading this book, since I had heard of the various film versions, starting with the 1925 Bela Lugosi film.  I have never been interested in seeing it because I absolutely detest the horror genre, whether in books or film. 

Most of the later film versions are basically faithful to the book's portrayal of Erik, the Phantom -- he is a monster, with a sick obsession for a young opera singer.  Furthermore, he is insanely jealous of the young aristocrat who courts her.  Because of his jealousy, he nearly ends up killing them both in the end.  In all fairness, I read the book a while back, so the author might have shown some compassion toward his character, and I simply can't remember that. 

The original story takes place in late nineteenth-century Paris.  The film versions are faithful to this, as well.

Erik has a horrible facial deformity, which is why he keeps his face covered with a mask.  He lives underneath the Paris Opera House, in an area permantnely flooded by water to the point that a lake has formed, which he crosses on a small boat.  Isolated for years, he has lived only for his music, which he composes on an immense organ.  Over the years he has constructed a dwelling for himself there.  He is a genius, having also contributed to the design of the Opera House years before.

When he hears Christine Daae sing one day, he is immediately captivated with her, but is afraid that she will reject him, so he pretends to be her "Angel of Music", and starts giving her voice lessons from behind a mirror in her dressing room.  Unbeknownst to her, the mirror is a secret entrance to a series of tunnels that take one down to the subterranean lake. 

Erik falls madly in love with Christine, but it's an obsessive, controlling love.  His jealousy is comparable to that of Othello for Desdemona, and its consequences are nearly as tragic as the ones in Shakespeare's immortal play.

Raoul de Chagny, the young Vicomte, is also in love with Christine.  They had been childhood friends, were later parted, and have now been reunited as adults.

Erik becomes more and more monstrous as the book progresses, even going as far as to torture Raoul.  Christine manages to escape with the Vicomte just in time, and, if I remember correctly, Erik wastes away and dies, pining for her. 

My first exposure to the tale was through Andrew Lloyd Webber's film version of his 1986 musical, which was released in 2004.  I fell head over heels in love with the Phantom!  Well, he was played by the Scottish actor Gerard Butler, so that was to be expected!   Then I read the Leroux novel, and was greatly disappointed.  Lloyd Webber portrayed the Phantom with much more compassion and humanity than Leroux did.  He's a tortured soul, longing for love, and mortally afraid of rejection.  I felt that Lloyd Webber captured the essence of the character much better than Erik's original creator did, which is highly ironic, as well as fascinating.  In fact, the story is thus seen to be based on the "Beauty and the Beast" archetype.

Sadly, in spite of this more humane rendition, Christine still chooses to escape with Raoul in the end, even though she is shown to have feelings for the Phantom.  And Erik, in contrast to Leroux's character, lets her leave with Raoul.  This is the essence of love -- to choose the happiness of the beloved above everything else, even if it causes pain to the one who loves...

Of course I cried and cried at the end of the movie.  I barely did so at the end of Leroux's book.  Still, I couldn't tolerate the fact that Erik could not have Christine's love in the 2004 movie.  I could see why they couldn't possibly be together in the book, due to Erik's horrible nature.  I felt that Webber's Erik should have had the chance to have Christine's love, however. 

That was when I discovered a website --  -- which allows people to create stories around favorite book or film characters.  So I began to write stories about the Phantom of the Opera, and in each and every one of them, Erik at last wins Christine's love! 

This became an obsession for a while, and I started several stories about the Phantom.  Only one is finished -- a one-shot titled "Miracle in Central Park". It's a modern retelling of the story.  All the stories I've posted on the site are variations and even entire departures from the original tale, but they all have one thing in common: a happily-ever-after ending for Erik and Christine.  Of course, in order to achieve this, I have changed Erik's nature even more than Webber has.  He's not as evil as he appears to be.

I am not alone in this; many other fan fiction authors have posted beautiful, romantic stories about the Phantom of the Opera on the site.  Of course, this is not the only book whose characters can be used to write fan fiction.  There are quite a few others, including The Twilight Saga.  I have written four Twilight stories, as well.

My pen name on the site is Angelmuse, although, for some reason, it doesn't show up when one does a search.  So, if anyone is interested, here's the link to my profile page, from which you can access any of my stories:


  1. I love Phantom of the Opera and have ALWAYS hated Christine for not choosing the Phantom. :(

    Amy's Follow Friday
    Check out my Summer Favorites Giveaway!

  2. Hopping through. I haven't read the book, but I listened to the soundtrack for years before seeing the musical. I always assumed Christine chose the Phantom. I was so upset when she didn't. I felt bad for the guy.
    My Hop

  3. Hi, Amy!

    Yes, this is a really beautiful, bittersweet tale, but as envisioned by Lloyd Webber. I totally dislike the Leroux novel! I'm upset, though, that even Webber fails to have Christine choose Erik....

    Thanks for dropping by! I'll go check out your hop post! : )

  4. Hi, Alison!

    If you haven't seen the film version of the musical, you're in for a treat! You've got to see it! You might not entirely like the voices of Christine and Erik, but visually, the movie is stunning!! And Mr. Butler is, as Mary Poppins would say, "truly scrumptious"!! Lol.

    Thanks for the visit!! I'm going over to check out your hop post!! : )

  5. Great pick! I haven't read the book! I always wanted too though! New follower!

    My Follow Friday

  6. I can't really blame Christine for not going with Erik - he was a little bit of a psycho :P The whole 'liking the bad boy' thing can only go so far.

    I would change the ending to the Sword of Truth series. Such a big build up (over multiple books) to have a pretty weak ending that spawned the very silly Law of Nines.

  7. Ah... I would have wanted to see them together at the end of the movie as well, I remember crying when the movie ended.

    New follower. :) My Friday and YA Giveaway

  8. Hi & Happy Friday :)

    I completely agree!

    My FF & 500 follower giveaway -

    Have a great weekend..

  9. New follower!
    I love Phantom of the Opera. It's true, the ending is so sad.

    HEre's mine:

  10. I can't say that I've ever read Phantom of the Opera but interesting pick and answer!

    I'm a new follower.

    Carmel @ Rabid Reads / Twitter

  11. Hi, Tia!

    I wouldn't recommend this book, at least not if you don't enjoy the horror genre. Instead, I would suggest you check out for stories that modify Erik's character substantially, and have a happy ending for him and Christine. Of course, if you're curious, you could read the book, and then the fan stories, and you'd see the difference.

    I would compare Leroux's Erik to Heathcliff in "Wuthering Heights". That's another books I hate!

    Thanks for commenting and following!! : )

  12. Hey, there, Jamie!

    Yeah, I know...Erik is definitely a psycho -- at least in Leroux's book. In Webber's musical and film, though, I see a slightly different Erik -- more of a tormented soul. He's even better in the fan stories. There are many excellent ones on Some of them run to more than 50 chapterws, while others are shorter.

    I remember reading one in Spanish that I immediately placed in my Favorite Stories section. It was lushly romantic!

    I haven't heard of the Sword of Truth series. Now that you've told me you didn't like the series ending, I might never check out these books.

    Thanks for the comment!! : )

  13. Hi, Ninna!

    Yes, the movie version was heartrending...especially since Erik decided to let Christine leave with Raoul in the end -- soemthing that Leroux's Erik did not do!

    Thanks for commenting and following!! : )

  14. Hey, Sharon!

    Glad you agree! I'm going to check out your FF post and giveaway! Woot!!

    Thanks for the comment!! : )

  15. LibrarySnake:

    Hi! I'm glad you, too, thought it was sad...but I wish Webber had made Erik even more sympathetic than Leroux did. Oh, well...

    I'll go check out your FF post.

    Thanks for the comment and the follow!! : )

  16. Hey there, Carmel!

    Thanks bunches for the comment! I'm glad you enjoyed reading my answer. I get a little carried away when I love a particular topic, but heck, that's the joy of writing, right?

    Thanks for becoming a follower, as well! : )

  17. Just spotted a cover off to the left (author: kendra leigh castle) and i'm off to book stalk it!:)

    I'm a new follower.

  18. I am an old follower!
    Hope you will stop by and check out my new multi-author blog 'The Writers Voice' with myself, Kristie Cook, Jamie Magee, Kim Richardson, Keary Taylor, Victoria Simcox, Jessica Sorensen, Brenda Pandos, Samantha Young, Jayde Scott, Megg Jensen, Danyelle Leafty and guest authors!

    The Writers Voice
    "Where you get to know the people behind the pages."

    If you suggest your favorite author in the comments we will see if we can contact them for an interview, guest post or other exclusive content!

    Emma Michaels

  19. This is the best answer ever!!! I love how passionate you are about this book. I didn't even realise that The Phantom of the Opera was a book. I always thought it was a musical Andrew Lloyd Webber created...If I were Christine and Gerard Butler was the Phantom, I'd run away with him in a second.

    I'm a new follower. My FF post: The Write Obsession

  20. Hi, Annie!

    Thanks for the comment and the follow!

    Yes, "Dark Awakening" was absolutely FANTASTIC!! So try to get it ASAP -- I'm sure you'll love it as much as I did! Review upcoming!

    Have a GREAT weekend!! : )

  21. Hi, Emma!

    Hey, thanks for being a faithful follower! I GREATLY appreciate it!!

    I'll be sure to check out your new blog! There are a coupld of authors I'd love for you guys to interview!

    Thanks for the comment!! : )

  22. Hi, Lan!

    Thank you so much for the compliment!! You've made my day!!!

    Yes, I am indeed VERY passionate about the Phantom! I don't think the original author, Leroux, portrayed Erik the way he should have. So I don't like his novel at all. I much prefer Webber's musical and film, but think that he, too, should have made Erik a more likable character...

    I'll go check out your FF post. Thanks for the comment and the follow!! : )

  23. Hi, Deb!

    I'll go check out your blog posts! Thanks for the comment!! : )


THIS IS NOW AN AWARD-FREE, AND TAG-FREE BLOG. Thanks for the compliment, though! : )

As of today, 9/23/18, I have permanently enabled comment moderation, due to a sudden rash of SPAM comments. I appreciate your patience!

Thanks for your thoughts on my posts! I always reply here, as well as comment back on your blog. Have a WONDERFUL day!! :)